Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joshua Doležal's avatar

Bob, you are a gem. Thanks for this original reporting. Your point about people cheering when DeSantis was at his most cruel reminded me of a little book by Carol Bly, in which she wittily recalls turning into a Republican briefly during an injury, when she suffered from such great pain that she quite literally could care only about herself. The book seems positively quaint, but I think you'd really like it: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/941161.

I like your closing, but it also captures how hardened our rhetoric about history has become. I agree with you that banning critical approaches to history is to be resisted at all costs. And I myself have used the term Native American Holocaust to capture the scale and the genocidal nature of many European-indigenous relations. But there is also some nuance in intertribal relations and in figures like Roger Williams and Jonathan Edwards, who sought to redress some of that colonial violence early on. James Welch captures much of this in Fools Crow. I guess I find it equally depressing to imagine Native American history being reduced to a political sound bite. There were some matriarchal nations, but tribes like the Blackfeet and Sioux were rigidly patriarchal, socialized their young men in what we might recognize as toxic masculinity, and socialized young women in ways that the woman you interviewed would reject. That is not the only story about those peoples, but it's the kind of thing that gets lost when genocide is the only story told. In truth, a lot of Native Americans, like Latino Americans, skew more conservative than liberal, are either Catholic or Protestant Christians, and own their fair share of firearms. I don't mean this in an adversarial way, but isn't there a fair chance that Chief Mahaska would have seen more of himself in a conservative leader like DeSantis than in someone like Joe Biden or even Nikki Haley?

Expand full comment
Suzanna de Baca's avatar

Thank you for your coverage.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts